22 April 2013

Treacherous Path to Shu

Sangokushi v33 is now done, hurray! Before I comment on it, here's a small status update:

I still can't find the vol 7 raws for Zero so there's nothing I can really do there, unless someone's kind enough to buy it and scan it themselves. If not, I'm sure it'll eventually show up a couple months down the road. I've also received Historie v7 cleans from a kind helper so I'm going to dedicate this week in finishing that. Next week, I'm going to get started on Sister Generator (1-volume oneshot collection by Samura), and once that's done, I'll come back to do more Sangokushi.

Now, going back to Sangokushi, there are two things I wanted to comment on, and they both take place in chapter 208 "The Two Suns." In the letter that Sun Quan sends to Cao Cao, the manga simply has Cao Cao inferring that Sun Quan's also beset by some trouble from his promise to not pursue Cao Cao if he retreats now. In the actual novel, Sun Quan's letter makes no such promise. Instead, he reminds Cao Cao how Wu is still under threat whether or not Cao Cao backs out on his disastrous campaign, which finally convinces Cao Cao to swallow his pride and withdraw.

The second, and more important, thing I wanted to comment on was Zhang Zhao's suggestion at the very end. His plan can be summarized in two main points: A) tie Liu Bei down in Shu by having Liu Zhang turn on him  B)combined forces of Zhang Lu and Sun Quan quickly overwhelm Jingzhou.

However, even after thinking about his plan for some time, I still don't think it makes any sense. Let's start with part A of his plan. There's no way Shu would ever turn on Liu Bei willingly. The first problem is whether Liu Zhang will even believe in Sun Quan's warning letter. If the vast majority of his retainers warning him against Liu Bei wasn't enough to convince him, why would he believe in a letter sent by the diplomatically distant Sun Quan? Secondly, it's quite unlikely that Shu would actually attack Liu Bei. If Shu's too weak to even handle Zhang Lu alone, which is why they invited Liu Bei in the first place, why on earth would Shu willingly fight Liu Bei? In the story (minor spoiler ahead), Shu is only forced to turn on Liu Bei when Liu Zhang reads Zhang Song's secret letter and realizes he has no choice but to fight. But there's no way in hell Zhang Zhao could have predicted this in advance. Also, Zhang Zhao is seriously underestimating Liu Bei if he thinks Liu Bei will just hesitate and fail to prioritize either front.

Now let's move to part B. Wu should know that Liu Bei still left a sizeable garrison in Jingzhou, under the capable hands of Zhuge Liang, Zhao Zilong, Guan Yu, and Zhang Fei. That's pretty much an all-star lineup there. Unless Zhang Zhao has a brilliant follow-up plan, I don't think they can overwhelm Jingzhou quickly enough before Cao Cao intervenes again. Sure, Wu's strong enough to fend off Cao Cao's massive army, but that's only because of Wu's naval superiority. Conquering Jingzhou's going to be a matter of numerous sieges and land battles. Remember when Sun Quan and Zhou Yu tried it just before the latter died?

In short, I'm not saying it's impossible for Wu to capture Jingzhou, but I just don't see them pulling it off before Cao Cao intervenes and Zhang Zhao's plan doesn't significantly increase Wu's chances of success. Well, that's enough analysing from me.

Feel free to tell me if you agrees or disagree with my opinion.

Download:
Sangokushi v33:   Sendspace;   Depositfiles
Sangokushi c209:   Sendspace;   Depositfiles

19 comments:

  1. We must remember that Liu Bei conquered Hanzhong(That made Liu Bei the most dangerous) before losing Jingzhou. This is especially Guan Yu who was really arrogant towards Wu and that's what caused his loss in ROTK. Well, they succeeded and thanks to Cao Cao.(Otherwise, it would never have happened)

    ReplyDelete
  2. What's the status on Joe? Will you finish v12 before resuming Sangokushi?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Also curious on Joe's status

      Delete
    2. Joe's progressing simultaneously along with other projects. It's not one that I can quickly rush through, since its releases also depend on whenever my typesetter has time to work on the chapters.

      Delete
  3. Of Samura's works, I think I enjoy his less violent and more comedic stuff the most. Would be nice to see someone pick up Halcyon Lunch.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Just when I was sad that Samura-sama ended Mungen...you scanlate more of his work! Great timing!

    ReplyDelete
  5. http://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=68427

    When did volume 7 happen?

    ReplyDelete
  6. About Zero v7 - I'll be by a Kinokuniya next weekend and could possibly pick up a copy if they have one. Let us know if scans pop up before next Friday. o/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Alright, I'll post again here if I don't find anything by Friday.

      Delete
    2. Don't forget that volume 8 has been released as well!

      Delete
  7. Nice to read that you are going to do Sister Generator. A couple of the stories there (Emerald and Brigit's Dinner) are already translated, so that should save you some time.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Just wanna say thanks for doing Sangokushi. Start not long ago but love it :) And does this Joe something that good? Everyone seem to like it

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad to hear you like Sangokushi. As for Joe, it's a highly influential shounen sports manga that ran back in the 70s. A real classic, so give it a try. You never know if you might like something until you try it.

      Delete
    2. The beginning of Joe feels extremely dated, but once Joe meets Rikishi everything starts to come together. Great comic.

      Delete
  9. Cool, since I caught up w Sengokushi i'll try that then. Btw, you are planning to finish the whole Sengokushi right? just wondering since it's pretty old I can't even find raw :P

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you so much!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Although Zhang Zhao's plan was definetely overly optimistic in its expected results (his letter to Liu Zhang isn't even mentioned again in the following chapters of the novel if I recall correctly), I think it was definitely worth a try.
    The clash between the two Lius was bound to happen (Xuande's takeover was even part of a pledge he made for the borrowing of Jingzhou) and Sun Quan had every interest in hasten it to make it as bloody as possible and to give Liu Bei little time for building up his consent (thing he was already doing by the time he arrived, even though there is no explicit mention by Yokoyama Mitsuteru).
    Liu Zhang still definetely needed Liu Bei to protect the Riverlands, but you never know how these things play out, he could even turn himself to Cao Cao hoping to protect his life and his seat as a Governor.
    As for Wu's invasion of Jingzhou (BTW, I think you confused it with "Shu" in the translations of Pang Tong's third plan), it's not like Liu Bei's sizeable garrison and capable commanders would have keep on defending it while their ruler and brother was risking his life or being killed in the north.

    Talking about the manga itself, I found it kinda interesting how Xuande is made out to be much more determinate and less hypocrite in his conquest.
    I gotta say that I miss Xun Yu's death though.

    ReplyDelete